The manga series Kagurabachi has developed an extremely dedicated reader base over the past few months. These passionate fans have gone to great lengths to support the manga, including purchasing copies to be shipped internationally in order to boost sales numbers.
However, another Weekly Shonen Jump series titled Martial Master Asumi has recently been canceled by the publisher Shueisha due to poor sales.
Understandably disappointed followers of Martial Master Asumi have placed blame on the Kagurabachi fans, arguing that their series was superior and deserved to continue being serialized over Kagurabachi.
Martial Master Asumi by Kawada has ended this week with Chapter 32 in Weekly Shonen Jump Issue #11.
Volume 3 of the series will release on March 4, 2024, and final volume 4 will release on May 2. pic.twitter.com/bkIxTNilop
— Shonen Jump News (@WSJ_manga) February 8, 2024
This disagreement has sparked heated exchanges between the two fandoms on Platform X. Some of the reactions from both sides express anger and resentment over the outcome.
The Kagurabachi supporters fire back that the survival of any series depends on its commercial viability.
Meanwhile, the Martial Master Asumi fans bemoan what they feel is an injustice given the quality of their preferred manga. Emotions are clearly running high, fueling the ongoing war of words.
The core issues seem to be passion for one’s fandom competing with cold, financial realities in the publishing industry. This clash of perspectives continues to play out publicly as fans dig in to defend their stance.
Kagurabachi’s Fandom on Cancelled Manga and Unfair Criticisms
Followers of the manga Martial Master Asumi were clearly crestfallen when their preferred series was recently cancelled by the publisher of Weekly Shonen Jump magazine.
Having a beloved story come to an abrupt end sparked intense emotions, though some fans may be misdirecting their frustration unfairly.
Specifically, supporters of the popular manga Kagurabachi have come under fire. In their grief, some Martial Master Asumi enthusiasts made disparaging remarks about Kagurabachi, claiming it should have been the one axed instead.
Some even labeled it as rubbish, making their displeasure abundantly clear.
While understandable to vent when disappointed, insulting another manga series does little good. Every fandom is entitled to enjoy their entertainment of choice.
There are always financial pressures behind publishing decisions, weighing factors beyond any fan’s control.
However, directing negativity or bile at fellow enthusiasts rarely alleviates sadness over a canceled series.
There may be no perfect resolution, but keeping perspective could encourage more constructive discussion
The Kagurabachi supporters responded to defend their preferred manga amidst the criticism.
They argued there was no justification for denigrating another series, preferring instead to simply enjoy the media they like without putting down others.
The Kagurabachi fanbase also presented what they viewed as a reasonable explanation for why Martial Master Asumi was canceled while their manga continued.
As the tweet shows, the publishing company Shueisha makes calculated decisions based heavily on sales and rankings.
Shueisha has a reputation for being ruthless in determining which manga series are worthwhile to serialize long-term. The order of manga titles printed in the Weekly Shonen Jump magazine indicates their relative commercial performance, with the most popular near the front.
Since Martial Master Asumi consistently ranked at the very end of the table of contents, some fans were not surprised it got cut by the publisher.
Understanding Fandom Dynamics
Essentially, the Kagurabachi supporters suggested market forces dictated one manga’s survival over the other. While that reality may still frustrate Martial Master Asumi’s followers, lashing out may not change anything.
There are always financial calculations occurring behind the scenes at major publishing houses. So while fans may feel powerless, insults likely won’t resurrect a canceled manga.
In addition to explaining Shueisha’s logic, some netizens noted that fans possess some power to support the series they enjoy.
For example, Kagurabachi’s passionate readers, known as Bachibros, went so far as to have the latest volume shipped internationally – an effort the manga artist thanked them for. This level of dedication can sway publishers.
In contrast, Martial Master Asumi’s followers may regret not taking more overt steps to bolster their preferred series. So while Shueisha made the ultimate call, fans are not powerless in influencing decisions. Their support, or lack thereof, sends a message.
However, despite these perspectives, tensions between the two fandoms persisted unabated. The disappointment of having a beloved series canceled sparked heated emotions, particularly directed at the surviving manga.
While the fervent debates highlight how invested these communities are, there is sadness in seeing conflicts arise over business decisions. With a serial’s fate uncertain, readers may redirect their frustrations.
But these reactions often neglect wider factors, as publishers weigh many data points.
